Daily Mercury, Mackay, 5 July, 1947.
THE YONGALA.
Sir,— The possibility of the
wreck discovered near Cape Bowling
Green, in the vicinity ,of Ayr, being
the 36-year-old wreck of the
Yongala was of more than passing
interest to myself, as I was a
passenger from Sydney on that
ill-fated voyage, disembarking at
the old Flat Top anchorage. The
loss of such a fine vessel with all
hands constituted one of Australia's
greatest maritime disasters.
Cyclonic weather prevailed along
the coast. The data available then
was not as complete as that available
now by the extensive use of wireless;
and the ill-fated vessel left a safe
anchorage to sail into the teeth of a
gale.
Yongala was a steel screw steamer
of 3664 tons gross. She was only
eight years of age when lost. The
cost was £102,000, She was noted
for her speed. My first contact
with Yongala was in 1907, when
she was my means of transport
from Brisbane to Sydney. The
following year I made my initial
voyage to Mackay in the same
vessel. On that occasion the S.S.
Cooma was given nearly two
hours' start at Sydney. The
Yongala berthed at Brisbane two
hours ahead.
It was customary when the
Yongala was leaving port for the
ship's trumpeter to play a farewell
tune. I can still see the trumpeter
standing on the top deck, his trumpet
glinting in the sunlight, as the Yongala
left Sydney on that last tragic voyage,
and the tune he played was Auld
Lang Syne.
After an uneventful voyage Yongala
arrived at Flat Top anchorage on
March 23, 1911. After transhipping
passengers and cargo to and from
the connecting lighters it left the
anchorage at 1.40 p.m. the same
day.
Within a very short time after
the departure of the Yongala
from Flat Top, my cousin, the
late George Bond who was then
State meteorologist, advised the
signal station at the island that
cyclonic conditions prevailed
between Mackay and Townsvllle,
between Mackay and Townsvllle,
and to warn all shipping. Although
other vessels profited by the
warning, unfortunately the message
could not be passed on to the
Yongala. Wireless was practically
unheard of then.
other vessels profited by the
warning, unfortunately the message
could not be passed on to the
Yongala. Wireless was practically
unheard of then.
The last person to sight the
doomed vessel was the lighthouse
keeper at Dent Island, which
point she passed at 6.30 p.m., a
few hours after leaving the
anchorage. From then on the
Yongala passed beyond human ken,
to add one more to the long roll
of mysteries of the sea.— Yours
etc.
JOHN GRANT MACKAY,
Goldsmith-street, Mackay.
THE YONGALA
Lost In Cyclone
TWENTY-TWO YEARS AGO
(By .'Junius")
On March 21st, 1911, friends and
relatives of a number of passengers
assembled at a Brisbane wharf to bid
them God-speed. The travellers were
embarking on the 1825-ton steamer
Yongala for North Queensland ports,
and had anyone suggested the
possibility of their never reaching their
destination, or that the farewells were,
literally, being taken on the brink of
the grave, it is more than likely that
consternation would have been blotted
out by incredulity. The Yongala was
well-found, properly loaded and in
excellent trim, and was commanded by
Captain W. J. Knight, whose knowledge
of Northern Queensland conditions and
skill in the handling of large vessels
was beyond question. He also had under
him experienced officers, and a staunch,
well-trained crew.
On the same day, a small rotary
storm of great intensity was operating
about 130 miles north from Willis Island.
There was then no meteorological
station on Willis Island, so that nobody
knew of the storm's existence, and
even had its presence been suspected,
few people would have connected this
small, virulent body upwards of 1000
miles away with the proud steamer
which passed rapidly out of the Brisbane
River to the open sea and sped
northwards with her living freight.
On the 22nd at noon the Yongala
was not far from North Reef lighthouse.
A ship at sea really was more of a
colony in those days before wireless,
than now the ether carries its messages
of shore doings with incredible speed
and unswerving fidelity. The company
on board soon settled down to the
enforced isolation from the kind, and
looked forward to the next port when
contact with world doings would be
re-established. By this time, the cyclone
had moved on a south-south-west
course, and was about 50 miles west
south-west from Willis Island. These
two strangely unlike bodies had moved
much closer together in the last 24
hours. Their paths were converging,
and for a large ship and 120 (122)
souls the sands of life were running low.
120 SOULS ON BOARD.
On the morning of the 23rd the Yongala
steamed into Flat Top, the anchorage at
Mackay, where she landed 60 tons of
cargo and some passengers. Whatever
was the changing of personnel at Mackay,
when the Yongala steamed away on her
last journey at 1.40 p.m., she had on board
120 (122) souls made up of crew 72, 1st
class passengers 29, and 2nd class
passengers 19. About two hours after she
sailed the Meteorological Department at
Melbourne advised coastal towns that
cyclonic conditions prevailed between
Mackay and Townsville. That warning was
issued on data which were collected at
9 that morning and telegraphed to Melbourne.
The reason for this seems to have been
that Melbourne was the seat of the
Federal Government-that is to say, no
other reason worth considering has been
propounded. Whatever the reasons, the
facts were that the 9 a.m. readings
that day showed the existence of a
dangerous storm moving down on to the
coast, and a valuable ship and 120 lives
steamed to their doom, nearly five
hours after those observations were
taken without any warning reaching
them. Bureaucratic pundits in Melbourne
knew, but the master of a ship on the
Queensland coast with 120 (122) lives
in his charge knew nothing of the
menace ahead.
As the boisterous evening drew to a
close, lighthouse keepers at Dent Island,
which lay 58 miles from Flat Top anchorage
along the route taken by the Yongala saw
the smoke of a large steamer hurrying north
through Whitsunday Passage. The south-east
wind drove the smoke head of her, sometimes
enveloping her like a funeral pall.
As she drew near it was seen that she
was the Yongala, but although Dent Island
light station was for years described
presumably by some humourist as a signal
station, it was never connected or had any
means of connecting with the mainland.
Hence the station had no news of the mighty
force which lay ahead, and as the Yongala
surged majestically past at 6.30 she was
seen for the last time by mortals. As she
faded into the growing dusk (dusk = 6 p.m.)
and increasing welter of storm, the mists of eternity
closed down behind her and the sea gained
yet another tragic secret.
I disagree with this time. It would have been difficult to confirm the ship's identity well after dark and with overcast gale conditions developing.
Residents of Cannon Valley saw the steamer passing at dusk (6 p.m.) one hour after passing Dent Island.
From Dent Island the Yongala had
106 miles to run before reaching the
next light on Cape Bowling Green, and
although the area within the Barrier
widens out considerably after clearing
Whitsunday Passage, it is still far too
narrow for ships to fight out a battle
of life and death with a cyclone.
Additional to this, as the paths of the
cyclone and of the Yongala were
approximately at right angles to each
other, the south-east wind which drove
her on her way, and in such a feature
of Queensland coast weather over the
greater part of the year, actually was
the direction the wind would blow in
the forward left-hand quadrant of the
cyclone. That is to say, the Yongala
was within the cyclone field soon after
she left Flat Top anchorage, but there
was nothing on board to show that
the strong wind was other than a
seasonal south-easter. Only comparison of
barometer readings at ports along the
coast could tell this, and this, of
course, Captain Knight did not have.
Such poignant, wise words. The truth of the matter.
It took several years of agitation to get
that simple and obvious safeguard
established, but that exchange of
readings has been in vogue now for
upwards of 20 years, and was extended to
Western Australia. But bureaucracy
resisted strenuously this invasion by
citizens into its preserves.
"SIMPLY OVERWHELMED."
What actually happened on board the
doomed ship will, of course, never be
known. How long after night closed
down it was before Captain Knight
realised that the ship was running into
the path of a cyclone is, of course, a
matter for conjecture, but it is hardly
likely that any of the passengers knew
of the imminence of their danger until
the vessel was actually overwhelmed.
There were many theories, including an
explosion and a faint whistle : uncharted
rocks and even islands. Searching steamers
found a copper band on Nares Rock,
obviously the driving band of a shell fired
by one of the Queensland gunboats
Gayundah on Paluma - which used this
rock as a target when operating from
Bowen on training cruises. There remained,
however, very little doubt in the minds of
experienced men that the Yongala and the
cyclone centre met sometime in the small
hours of the 23rd when about half-way
between Capes Upstart and Bowling Green,
and that the Yongala was simply
overwhelmed.
It was closer to Cape Bowling Green, but the assessment was spot on.
The cleared track behind Cape Upstart,
in which huge trees were twisted like reeds
and thrown down like nine-pins, indicated
the fury of the gale.
It is common belief that no trace of
the vessel was even found. This is
wrong, as the beaches of islands to the
north were littered with scraps of
wreckage, much of it easily identifiable
as coming from the lost ship. But no
human bodies were ever found,
although the vessels Alert, Barratta,
Magnet, Ouraka, Tarcoola, and Teal
searched the whole of the reefs and the
coast from Cape Upstart to Lucinda
Point was patrolled by special bodies
of police.
Wireless has robbed sea travel along
the coast of North Queensland of many
of its old terrors. Had Willis Island
meteorological station been in existence,
the storm which was to wreck a proud
ship and carry consternation and
mourning into hundreds of homes, would
have been located on the day the Yongala
left Brisbane. As it was, the Yongala
was in the position of the train which
is sent out blindfolded to cross a line
of rails that another train is using,
with the Aniel of Death officiating as
time-keeper to ensure the two meeting
at the intersection.
Cloncurry Advocate, 24 March, 1934
Loss of the Yongala.
DISAPPEARANCE IN A CYCLONE.
The disastrous cyclone of last week.
when a number of luggers were
swamped and 79 lives lost brings to
mind other maritime disasters along
the Queensland Coast and we cull
the following regarding the loss of the
Yongala, twenty three years ago from
Cummins and Campbell's monthly
magazine of September, 1933; —
.. On Wednesday, March 29th, 1911,
flags were flying at half mast over a
number of the business houses and
public buildings of Townsville. The SS
Yongala was several days overdue on
a voyage from the South and all hopes
were lost of finding her. Captain Romer
the Harbourmaster, said it is simply
cruelty to try to keep up the hopes of
those who have friends on board.
On the previous Saturday the Harbour
master was quite satisfied that something
serious had happened when the vessel
had not come to port. Judging by where
some cargo had been found near Cape
Bowling Green, he had little doubt that the
vessel had struck a reef. The locality would
be about 22 miles east of Cape Upstart
(actually north), here there were masses
of big boulders which are covered at high tide.
To strike that reef the Yongala would
have to be only ten miles off her
course. In rough weather the captain
would try to keep in the centre of the
channel (which was precisely Yongala
was when she went down) but trouble
would arise from strong winds and thick
visibility. If the vessel did strike that reef it
was when she went down) but trouble
would arise from strong winds and thick
visibility. If the vessel did strike that reef it
would tear a hole in her side and she
might keep a float for a quarter of a
mile into 27 fathoms of water. Captain
Romer was of the opinion that the
vessel met with her disaster about
midnight on Thursday, March 23rd.
Extraordinary!! Time, exactly right.
The Yongala was a favourite
passenger and cargo steamer which
had been built in Newcastle, England,
to the order of the Adelaide Steamship
Company. Her gross register was 3,668
tons, length 350 feet, beam 45 feet and
depth 27 feet. For some years prior to
being transferred to the Queensland
service she was engaged to run to
West Australian ports. On her ill-fated
voyage the Yongala carried 49 passengers
and a crew of 72, including the Captain,
stewardesses and boys.
Within a few hours steaming from
Townsville 121 (122) persons went to
their deaths and not one body was
recovered. Truly it must have been the
most marvelous disaster that ever
occurred on an Australian coast.
The best known among the passengers
was Mr. Mathew Rooney, who was
accompanied by his wife and youngest
daughter. He was principal of the firm of
Rooney and Co and the business still
flourishes as Rooney Ltd.. Mr. Rooney
was a prominent figure in the public
life of Townsville. For a lengthy period
he served as Alderman on the City
Council and was an active member
of the Harbour Board and the Hospital.
In his charitable work he was always ably
assisted by his wife. His daughter, Miss
Lizzie Rooney was a noted vocalist and
her loss was greatly felt by the Sacred
Heart Choir.
Besides the loss of Mr. Rooney, the
Townsville Hospital mourned for the
death of Nurse Buxton, who was
returning from a holiday. It was stated
that she had her wedding in view.
Then there was a popular sporting man,
Mr. J. Campbell, who was bringing up a
Then there was a popular sporting man,
Mr. J. Campbell, who was bringing up a
racehorse named Moonshine for Mr.
W. Duncan of south Townsville. It was
known that the horse was on board.
Among the passenger list for Cairns
appeared the names of Mrs. Abl.
Murray and four children; Mrs. S.W.
Davids and Mrs. B.J. Magee.
Another well known northern name
was A.S. Letta of Mungana, and
formerly of the Excelsior Hotel.
For several weeks the coast from
Cape Upstart to Lucinda Point was
searched by all sorts of craft. It was
impossible to locate the lost steamer,
but wreckage was picked up as far as
the Palm Islands, and five mail bags
with letters for Townsville and Cloncurry
were found by kanakas.
On Cassady's Beach near Ingham
the writer of these notes saw a letter
for one in the Cloncurry district. It was
perfectly legible.
A mail hamper containing parcels was
recovered by the tug Alert. The addresses
were undecipherable, but the printed labels
showed that certain articles came from the
firms of Finney Isles and Co, Pike Bros. and
T.C. Beirne. After considerable amount of
trouble the owners were found.
At Palm Island, a cribbage board was
picked up marked "Smoke Room Yongala",
also a piece of 4 by 1 pine painted white.
On this was fixed a slab of ivory with the
On Cassady's Beach near Ingham
the writer of these notes saw a letter
for one in the Cloncurry district. It was
perfectly legible.
A mail hamper containing parcels was
recovered by the tug Alert. The addresses
were undecipherable, but the printed labels
showed that certain articles came from the
firms of Finney Isles and Co, Pike Bros. and
T.C. Beirne. After considerable amount of
trouble the owners were found.
At Palm Island, a cribbage board was
picked up marked "Smoke Room Yongala",
also a piece of 4 by 1 pine painted white.
On this was fixed a slab of ivory with the
intimation, "Passengers are requested
to switch the light off when leaving the
cabin."
The aboriginals found a case of cooking
apples with A.L. over T. in a circle.
The aboriginals found a case of cooking
apples with A.L. over T. in a circle.
On Eclipse Island a seaman's chest
was washed ashore bearing the initials
J.R.D. This had been the property of
Mr. J.R. Donald the second officer of
the Yongala. The captain's name was
W. Knight.
In the Magnet Mr. R. Haylee performed
extensive search work along the coast
to Cape Bowling Green; produce of
various kinds were picked up on the
beaches, notably a bag of pollard
C.S.R. over B. Pumpkins lay scattered
in several places.
A considerable amount of wreckage was
found by captain Tutty of the Alert who
explored Keeper's Reef. One object was
a door with fancy glass panels containing
the lettering "Festina Lente, Inc. 1900".
Festina lente means hasten slowly. The
pane of glass containing the word Lente
was broken. The date was taken to refer
to the incorporation of the Adelaide Steamship
Company.
Some of the other vessels out in search for
the Yongala were the steamships Tacoola;
Ouraka; Teal and Barratta.
A considerable amount of wreckage was
found by captain Tutty of the Alert who
explored Keeper's Reef. One object was
a door with fancy glass panels containing
the lettering "Festina Lente, Inc. 1900".
Festina lente means hasten slowly. The
pane of glass containing the word Lente
was broken. The date was taken to refer
to the incorporation of the Adelaide Steamship
Company.
Some of the other vessels out in search for
the Yongala were the steamships Tacoola;
Ouraka; Teal and Barratta.
At the time of the disaster Hon. D.F. Denham,
then premier of Queensland was a visitor to
Townsville and he used his authority to the
full in the search for the missing vessel. When
hope was given up, public meeting was held
in the Town Hall for the purpose of forming a
relief fund for the widows and orphans of men
who went down with the ship.
The Mayor, Alderman George Murray, occupied
the Chair. There were present Bishop Frodsham,
Foley M.L.R., J. Botten, D. Baxter, W. Dalgliesh,
G.W. Chapman, P.Grant, H.R. Thompson, R.T.
Hartley, A. Campbell, C.J. Kendarine, Major
Galdersmith and the Town Clerk, H.G. Johnson.
Foley informed the meeting that as far as
Queensland was concerned the Workers'
Compensation Act would not cover the case
of the seamen. A representative committee
was formed to collect subscriptions and to
organise benefit entertainments.
The brutal reality of a bygone era.
The Yongala was insured for £ 90,000, one
The brutal reality of a bygone era.
The Yongala was insured for £ 90,000, one
fourth of the risk was undertaken by the
Adelaide Steamship Company who were
the owners. The remaining three fourths
was divided between the Union Insurance
Company, the Canton Insurance Company
and the South British Insurance Company.
The cost of the construction of the vessel
was £ 102,000.
It would have made financial sense to make every effort to find the wreck, and because she went down in a cyclone in relatively shallow waters, could theoretically have been salvaged / re-floated. This had been done in other cases of this era.
But perhaps the objective of the Adelaide Steamship Company was to stick to the 'striking a rock' theory rather than acknowledge Yongala's un-seaworthiness in a severe storm = culpability = costly payouts.
On her northern voyage she was heavily
loaded with merchandise of all kinds.
Her last port of call was Mackay.
She was only 29% full, re cargo.
It would have made financial sense to make every effort to find the wreck, and because she went down in a cyclone in relatively shallow waters, could theoretically have been salvaged / re-floated. This had been done in other cases of this era.
But perhaps the objective of the Adelaide Steamship Company was to stick to the 'striking a rock' theory rather than acknowledge Yongala's un-seaworthiness in a severe storm = culpability = costly payouts.
On her northern voyage she was heavily
loaded with merchandise of all kinds.
Her last port of call was Mackay.
She was only 29% full, re cargo.
Captain Knight was a man of great
experience and was considered to be
one of the most capable men in the
Adelaide Company's service. He first
arrived in Australia in the ship Southern
Belle, which landed passengers and
cargo at Rockhampton in 1873. Shortly
before reaching the coast, this vessel
ran into a furious cyclone and was saved
by a miracle
Belle, which landed passengers and
cargo at Rockhampton in 1873. Shortly
before reaching the coast, this vessel
ran into a furious cyclone and was saved
by a miracle
N.B.— It is the opinion of Mr. R.
Hayles that the Yongala was struck
side on by the cyclone and turned
over. The locality of the disaster might
be twenty miles east of Cape Cleveland
in 12 to 15 fathoms of water. It is possible
that the remains of the unfortunate vessel
will be discovered.
It was actually 30 miles east of Cape Cleveland. Mr. Hayles certainly had a grip on the reality of the tragedy.
The weather was threatening
when we came alongside the
Yongala about midday and the
skipper, Captain William Knight
It was actually 30 miles east of Cape Cleveland. Mr. Hayles certainly had a grip on the reality of the tragedy.
courtesy Google Earth |
Truth, Sydney, 5 October, 1952
Letters To TRUTH
A Final Word
On Yongala
The s.s. Yongala (3664 tons) was
definitely lost on the night of March
23, 1911. I was the last man to leave
the ill-fated passenger ship at Flat Top Island.
I was a member of the
crew of the 90-ton tender,
Brinawar, based on Mackay,
which met the Yongala at
Flat Top, then the port for the
North Queensland sugar town.
Flat Top, then the port for the
North Queensland sugar town.
The weather was threatening
when we came alongside the
Yongala about midday and the
skipper, Captain William Knight
would not wait for any cargo.
Passengers and mail were
transhipped to the Brinawar
Passengers and mail were
transhipped to the Brinawar
and we put mail and luggage
aboard the Yongala.
aboard the Yongala.
A few minutes before the Yongala
sailed for Townsville, a black cat,
which had strayed aboard the
Brinawar in Mackay the previous
sailed for Townsville, a black cat,
which had strayed aboard the
Brinawar in Mackay the previous
night, raced across our bridge deck.
Our captain, who was a Swede, had
told me earlier that I must get rid of
the black cat when we got back to
shore. He was a superstitious sailor
of the old school. At the sight of the
cat on the bridge he reminded me
again about getting rid of it.
the black cat when we got back to
shore. He was a superstitious sailor
of the old school. At the sight of the
cat on the bridge he reminded me
again about getting rid of it.
The chief mate of the Yongala
was a friend of mine and I asked
him if he would give the cat a
was a friend of mine and I asked
him if he would give the cat a
passage for luck. 'Sure.' he said,
'bring him aboard.' I took the cat
up and said goodbye to the mate
'bring him aboard.' I took the cat
up and said goodbye to the mate
just as the Yongala was preparing
to head out into the cyclone which
was to spell her doom.
to head out into the cyclone which
was to spell her doom.
The Yongala was sighted
by Dent Island lighthouse
six hours after leaving Flat
Top and that was the last
ever heard of the eight-year
old ship and 120 souls on
board.
Had falling tides in the
Pioneer River not forced
the Brinawar to leave
Mackay half an hour before
her scheduled sailing time
for Flat Top, there would
have been 123 lives lost on
the Yongala.
When we put out to meet
the Yongala we left three
commercial travellers behind
in Mackay. We put their
samples aboard the Yongala
and when we returned to
Mackay we faced three angry
men on the wharf.
I remember vividly the
abuse they hurled at the
Swedish skipper of the
Brinawar. Two days later
they came back and
apologised very meekly when
there were no tidings of
the Yongala.
Two of the mailbags
we put aboard the Yongala
were the first things washed
up from the wreck,
which has never been
found. The mail apparently
had not been stowed
away.
JOHN LUCK,
1 Windmill St.,
Miller's Point.
Truth, Sydney, 31 August, 1952
SKIPPER of the
Yongala, Captain
William Knight,
one of the most popular
and skilled seamen on the
coastal service, apparently
had some premonition of
the disaster that was to
overtake his ship.
Just before she left the
berth, he told a friend that
this would be his last trip
'in the old girl.'
'They'll never part the
Yongala and me,' he said,
quietly.
Sunday Mail, Brisbane, 1 April, 1934.
TRAGIC LOSS
OF
s.s. YONGALA
Foundered in Cyclone: 140 Lives Lost
Search for Wreckage Recalled
The recent cyclonic disaster in
the North has recalled many such
disastrous happenings of the past.
In the following article Mr. Allan
M'Kie tells of the foundering of
the s.s. Yongala in a cyclone be-
tween Mackay and Townsville
with the loss of all lives— 140 (122)
passengers and crew — and narrates
some facts never previously published.
(By Allan McKie)
ON the night of March 24, 1911,
the north coast of Queensland was
swept by a terrific cyclone, and the
full fury of the storm struck the s.s.
Yongala somewhere between Mackay
and Townsville. She disappeared be-
neath the waves, and from then till
now no trace of the ill-fated vessel,
her passengers and crew, has ever
been discovered. Her disappearance
remains one of the sea's mysteries, and
will probably never be solved till the
sea gives up its dead. Her loss will
ever be sorrowfully remembered by
the relatives and friends of the 140 (122)
poor souls who with their vessel, in
the dead of night, were hurled to their
last rest.
While many people remember the
wreck and the first evidences of her
loss, a racehorse and bangle, which
were picked up near Alligator Creek,
south of Townsville, very few ever
heard more. That a considerable
amount of wreckage, definitely proved
as having come from the ill-fated vessel,
was discovered, never came to light.
Two weeks later, at the Palm Islands,
40 miles north of Townsville, some of
the residents of the late Harry Butler's
health resort decided to make a
thorough search for traces of the
missing ship. Harry Butler was an
experienced pilot, and knew every reef
and cay along that part of the coast.
Many hours were spent poring over
a chart, and from the knowledge of
the time the Yongala had been last
seen, passing Dent Island Light (be-
tween Mackay and Bowen), we
endeavoured to work out her
approximate position when the
cyclone struck her.
FIXING LOCATION OF THE
DISASTER
For a few days after the cyclone the
wind blew towards the south, and any
wreckage found was south of Cape
Cleveland; but with a change to the
east all wreckage from then on was
found north of that point.
Butler said that at the Four-foot Rock,
abreast of the cape, the current set
due north and south. With the
change in the drift and his opinion
of the vessel's position, he decided she
had met her fate on the Wheeler
Reef, about 26 miles east and slightly
north of Townsville.
Townsville before being able to start
searching for the boat, we confined our
early attentions to looking for wreckage
on the adjacent islands. In Butler's ketch,
the Palm Queen, we made many visits
to them, and later went to the Barrier
and Wheeler Beefs.
WRECKAGE FOUND
Having noticed some odd objects on
Eclipse Island (4½ miles south-west),
our primary endeavours were centred
The splintering was quite different
from the bruising and chafing from
contact with the reef.
An important analytical observation confirming that Yongala was destroyed by the cyclone and not by striking a reef.
On another occasion the vessel's
cribbage board was found by one of
our number, Mr. Staines, of New Farm,
Brisbane. (Recently he told me he
had parted with the relic.) Another
day produced stronger evidence, as in
addition to some cases of butter,
petrol, and kerosene, a steward's box
and cap were found side by side. The
butter was in splendid order, full proof
of the short time it had been in the
water.
As the box and cap were the first
personal effects recovered, the full
force of the disaster was more
poignantly brought before us.
Back again at the homestead a
thorough check was made of the
various articles found in the box. We
were much disappointed at the
complete absence of identification marks.
By advice from the shipping company
concerned the clothing was handed
over to the natives at the aboriginal
settlement on the Island.
LIFEBELTS RECOVERED.
Our next visit was made to
Brisk and Esk Islands (adjoining
Eclipse), and at the first named, in
addition to a haul of timber, we re-
covered the keel and garboard strake
of a ship's boat, and floating amongst
the coral a boat's mast with rigging
complete.
It was reported at the Inquiry that portion of lifeboat 1, port side, was recovered, and this might very well have been the lifeboat in question.
The lifeboat drifted north. If there had initially been survivors on board who sent up a distress rocket, allegedly heard the next day, Friday 24 March, (whistle and explosion) the sounds would not have been heard south of Cape Bowling Green as reported, but further north relative to the site of the disaster.
Another extract fleshes this out:
Another extract fleshes this out:
The Courier Mail, 19 July, 1954
At 9 am on the day the
ship was reported missing,
Mr. T. Mitton and I were
shifting some of his cattle to
high ground when we heard
three loud blasts of a ship's
whistle and a shot 'like a dis
tress signal.' I swam the
Hannah branch of the lower
Burdekin and went to Ayr,
about 10 or 12 miles, and
reported this to the Post Office,
from where a message
was sent to Harbour Master at
Townsville.
From where we were, the
direction would be east of
-Cape Bowling Green. —
E. Tappenden, 31 Manson Parade,
Yeronga.
At the latter, results were even more
encouraging, as a life buoy and two
lifebelts came to light. The latter bore
evidence of having been used, as the
lacing was knotted together and had
been forcibly torn apart from the
canvas on one side.
This is the first reference in all the material I have perused which refers to a human being who anticipated disaster by donning a lifebelt. What happened subsequent to that is a matter for conjecture. It is possible, given the close association with the remnants of a lifeboat, that this person was on board but succumbed as the lifebelt was torn from his or her body by the hurricane conditions. It is a moment for pause and reflection on the lives lost in this disaster.
In addition to these relics we found
the top rail of the companionway
lying on the sand, and close by, nearly
buried, two boards. One bore the
words, "Smoking Saloon," the other
'This vessel has twin screws.'
Yongala had a single propeller. I am puzzled by the reference and a possible explanation?
SEARCHING FOR THE VESSEL.
Although results so far had definitely
proved the loss, we were no closer
to achieving our main object, the
finding of the vessel. To that end we
decided on a trip to portions of the
Barrier Reef and from thence to the
Wheeler Reef. To help our search
we had a kerosene tin, the ends of
which had been removed and a piece
of glass inserted at one. With this
we could see the bottom clearly at
about 60ft.
Practical and ingenious.
Notwithstanding a careful search at
different spots of the Barrier Reef
results were negative; we did not even
discover any wreckage. On the Wheeler
Reef we met the same disappointment.
Sailing home in a direct line with
the Palm Group a small floating
parcel was overtaken, which Dick (one
of the ketch's native crew) hauled
aboard with his fishing spear. This
turned out to be a lot of catalogues,
but the writing on them was so badly
disfigured as to be practically in-
decipherable. From a few odd non-
obliterated letters we came to the
conclusion that the parcel had been
sent by T. C. Beirne and Co., Brisbane.
The catalogues were unfortunately use-
less, even as relics, having been,
practically reduced to pulp.
PASSENGER'S BOX
When nearing home, about 41 miles
from the Great Palm, Dick pointed
to the end thereof and said, 'Bokis
(box) over there.' We sailed to the
spot and after some hours hard work
recovered a solid yellow wooden box,
about 4 ft. long, heavily bound with
rope. This bore the words: 'Mrs.
S. H. Wanby, passenger to Townsville.'
We communicated particulars of our
find to the Police Inspector at Towns-
ville, and received his advice, "Mrs.
Wanby was a passenger on the ill-
fated Yongala. "She had lived in
Charters Towers many years, and was
on the eve of completing a trip round
the world. She had braved the terrors
of the deep over many thousands of
miles, and then was lost almost in
sight of home.
The box was sent in due course to
the inspector, to be handed the
deceased lady's relatives. Later we
heard it contained presents for them.
Practically nothing more was found
and from the small amount of wreck-
age, and from the splintered state
of all timber picked up we all came
firmly to the opinion that the ship's
bottom had been ripped open.
We know from the wreck that Yongala's bottom is intact.
Had she foundered, as many had claimed,
surely her decks would have burst and
released a large quantity of cargo and
more effects.
There certainly was a fair amount of light cargo from the lower hold discovered along the coast.
From the constant direction of the
drift, direct from the Wheeler Reef to
the Palm Group, after many weeks'
searching, we left the island, firmly
convinced that Harry Butler's idea
that the Yongala was lost somewhere
about the former spot was correct.
No, it was not.
The Telegraph, Brisbane, 29 March, 1934
The Telegraph, Brisbane, 29 March, 1934
OLD WRECK RECALLED.
SIR, — Your correspondent, "G.S." writes
in Friday's "Telegraph" regarding the
anniversary of the loss of the inter-State
coastal steamer Fougald through encountering
a cyclone between Mackay and Townsville
on March 23, 1911. I think he is sadly astray
in regard to the name of the steamer.
I take It "G.S." was referring to the extremely
high-funnelled Yongala, which, if
my memory is not playing me a trick, was
lost between Mackay and Townsville on
the date mentioned. The Yongala was in
command of Captain J. Knight, who was
noted for his fearlessness in bad weather.